Wilson County News - Roadmap for America

November 3, 2008 | 2 comments

During the campaign there was a lot of rhetoric on health care, but neither side discussed the real problems, issues or solutions. The problem is not that 45 million people have no health insurance. The problem is that for those who do have health insurance, it is like paying on a second mortgage.

The problem is that medical care costs have spiraled out of control and the political debate has been simply a matter of how government could defray the cost. That is, there has been no attempt to address what is driving the costs inordinately high.

Issues are Complex. Just as the real issues cannot be covered in slogans or sound bites, a comprehensive discussion is not possible in a single column article. Comprehensive discussions are available as entire chapters in the book this column profiles. However, as a brief overview there are four basic issues. The first is the threat of frivolous litigation, which automatically adds 10 to as much as 30% to the cost of medical services. To date our politicians have not made a good faith effort to deal with this issue.

For the most part, the Republicans have tried to limit awards or exempt specific industries from lawsuits. The Democrats, being primarily comprised of lawyers, have not cared to make any changes whatsoever.

The fundamental problem is that perjury statutes are not enforced in civil cases. This has allowed a disgraceful situation to occur in which a cadre of doctors, engineers, chemists, etc. have evolved into professional witnesses. �Professionals� who make their living by skewing testimony for either a large fee, or in some cases a percentage of the award!

Another problem is the culture of our medical system that does not consider the disparate competence between doctors, but instead places all physicians in authoritarian roles. A particularly outrageous manifestation of this concept is the fact that a �prescription� is often required to obtain simple laboratory analysis!

Consolidation in the hospital industry has led to many hospitals having an oligopoly and sometimes even monopolistic pricing powers within specific markets. Beyond that, unethical billing procedures have become an accepted practice. Evidence of this are Medicare audits where billing includes unnecessary or even procedures never performed. Cash patients are typically billed much higher fees than Medicare or insured patients (since no one will review the bill).

Because of the authoritarian culture within our medical system, patients do not �shop around� for reasonably priced services. This in turn feeds those within the industry with a propensity to overcharge.

There is ample opportunity to obtain both lower cost services and insurance. Domestically there are independent laboratories that typically charge a fraction of what is the norm for hospital laboratories. Physicians in private practice likewise will be much less expensive than physicians aligned with hospitals. Becoming an educated medical care shopper can save 30 to 60% for most services.

Overseas, savings are even more dramatic. Although little known to most Americans, a huge global medical �tourism� industry has developed. Singapore, Thailand and India have developed excellent and modern hospitals primarily for treating foreign patients. Although the primary purpose was to serve citizens of the British Commonwealth who could not get services due to socialized medicine in their own countries; Americans can and are taking advantage of this option.

According to the Economist magazine, costs are roughly 15% of comparable American hospitals. Obviously, the medical care lobby will try to limit access to offshore care. This is something that will be done back stage and will not become part of medical care politics. But it is something all of us must guard against. For whatever reason, any of us could find ourselves without health insurance, and being able to access reasonably priced care is an option we should not let our politicians take away.

Next Blog Entry (November 10, 2008) »

« Previous Blog Entry (October 28, 2008)

Your Opinions and Comments

Mike
Floresville
November 30, 2008 9:08pm

Report Abuse

When hospitals are for-profit, they are always looking for new ways to make profits. It doesn't matter if that makes for efficient use of resources. It doesn't matter if ... Read More

Mike
Floresville
November 7, 2008 2:57am

Report Abuse

One way to help change healthcare would be a law that would allow an individual to forego his right to litigate against a doctor. That would remove the necessity for expensive ... Read More

Share your comment or opinion on this story!

Red bold fields are required.

E-mail me when other users comment (login required)
Skip the two-word CAPTCHA code (login required)

Your Name:	Your Location:
Your E-Mail Address:	Your e-mail address will not be published. You will not receive any unsolicited e-mail by using this form.
Your Comment:
To confirm that you are a real person (not an automated spammer), please type the two words that you see in the box above. The words are designed to be slightly difficult to read, so just do the best you can. Don�t worry: if you get it wrong, you�ll have another chance. Or you can click the button to see another pair of words. For the visually impaired, or if you prefer to listen to and type a series of numbers, click the button.

By submitting this form, you authorize posting of your name, your location (if entered), and your comment. Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off-topic, defamatory, obscene, vulgar, abusive, threatening or that represent an invasion of privacy or a personal attack. By submitting this form, you furthermore acknowledge that you have read, have understood, and agree to the complete wilsoncountynews.com Terms of Use. If wilsoncountynews.com discovers any comment that in our judgment violates our Terms of Use, we will remove the comment. Users who in our judgment violate the Terms of Use may be banned or blocked from all or part of the web site. Additionally, wilsoncountynews.com may for any reason, at our discretion elect to remove any comment; choose to not display any comment; and ban or block any user from all or part of the web site. Click here to review our complete Terms of Use.