Thursday, April 28, 2016
1012 C Street  •  Floresville, TX 78114  •  Phone: 830-216-4519  •  Fax: 830-393-3219  • 

WCN Site Search


Preview the Paper Preview the Paper

Preview this week's Paper
A limited number of pages are displayed in this preview.
Preview this Week’s Issue ›
Subscribe Today ›

Lost & Found


VideoLost: Pitbull mix, brindle male, answers to Jake, since April 7 on I-37 between 536 and Hardy Rd. No questions, help Jake come home to his family, 361-765-7373.
Found: Female dog with dark brown and tan highlights, on Hwy. 87, Adkins. Call Andrea at 623-512-8099.

VideoMarma went missing near FM427/CR537. F/Terrier mix/30lbs/Orange/Red medium length fur. Can be extremely shy- please call or text 210-440-3889 if seen.
More Lost & Found ads ›

Help Wanted

Seeking individual to work in a local child-care center, paid holidays, etc., must be high school grad or GED. Apply in person at Cubs Country Childcare, 212 FM 1346 in La Vernia.
Part-time position, unique opportunity for someone to learn the swimming pool business, must have own transportation. Call Beverly, 210-382-4674.
More Help Wanted ads ›

Featured Videos





Video Vault ›
You’ve been granted free access to this subscribers only article.

Agriculture Today


Cattlemen respond to GIPSA congressional hearings




E-Mail this Story to a Friend
Print this Story
Guest Editorial
July 27, 2011 | 3,124 views | Post a comment

by Allan Sents

In light of the recent hearings held on the Hill in Washington, D.C., the U.S. Cattlemen’s Association would like to address a few points that were repeatedly left out of the discussion. In the Senate, Chairwoman Debbie Stabenow convened “The State of the Livestock Industry in America” hearing at the beginning of the month. The cattlemen’s association appreciates Stabenow convening this hearing as with discussions beginning on the 2012 Farm Bill and the future of a livestock title is discussed, the association welcomes such opportunities to discuss the current issues facing the industry.
While the Senate hearing sought to address all issues within the livestock industry, the House Small Business Committee Subcommittee on Agriculture, Energy, and Trade’s Hearing “Regulatory Injury: How USDA’s [U.S. Department of Agriculture] Proposed GIPSA [Grain Inspection, Packer and Stockyards Administration] Rule Hurts America’s Small Businesses” focused solely on the GIPSA proposed rule, and notably carried with it an overtly biased platform in which to discuss the issue.
The Senate livestock hearing highlighted some successes in farm policy, including natural resource programs, record commodity prices driven by strong exports, and pending free trade agreements to open more export markets. The USDA’s GIPSA proposed rule to increase fairness in the marketing of livestock and poultry was one of the more controversial topics of the day and was discussed extensively. Unfortunately, the hearing failed to clarify many misconceptions about the rule. Numerous participants and senators railed against the proposed rule, yet none of those opposed to the rule offered any suggestions on what their remedies would be. ...
USDA Chief Economist Dr. Joe Glauber did an admirable job of describing his role in conducting a cost-benefit analysis of the proposed rule. He recognized the difficulties in evaluating the effect of the rule before implementation and response in the marketplace becomes known. An interesting question for Glauber might have been what the effect would be if in fact the rule is implemented as intended by the authors and current grids rewarding premium cattle are not affected.
A confusing aspect that rule opponents, such as Steve Hunt from U.S. Premium Beef, bring up is the burden of justifying different prices paid in the marketplace. Premium Beef, of all packers, appears to have a detailed system in place that already does that. The Premium Beef grid is based on third party, USDA-reported prices. A detailed explanation of premiums and discounts is currently reported for each group of cattle settled on their grid. To use the language of the law, how could a “reasonable” person refute that process as being “unjustly discriminatory”? It seems rule opponents resort to “fear mongering” to dream up outlandish possibilities to make their case.
Another perplexing scenario was presented by ranking member Pat Roberts. Roberts began his comments by misquoting GIPSA Administrator J. Dudley Butler. Butler did say once that the 90-year-old Packers and Stockyards Act was a “plaintiff lawyer’s dream” because of vague terms like “unreasonable” and “undue preference.” That ambiguity was also the reason Congress directed GIPSA to clarify terms in the act. ... Butler has said he intends to provide the clarification Congress directed to prevent such a scenario from taking place.
Roberts was also critical of the USDA extending beyond Congressional intent. However, the USDA is accountable to the entire congressional intent going back to the formation of the Packers and Stockyards Act in 1921. The act was implemented to be different from anti-trust law and provide unique protection to the livestock industry. Recent court rulings have distorted and confused those protections.
Presumably, one of the rules Roberts opposes is clarification of the term “business justification.” Sen. Jon Tester introduced legislation in 2008 to do just that. That legislation was defeated. Perhaps though, the senator could explain why, in our Republic, personal conduct should determine what is legal instead of the “rule of law.” Why does one packer’s practice make it acceptable for another to adopt a similarly discriminatory practice, when the law states differently?
Another misinterpreted term is “competitive harm.” Some judges have interpreted this to mean a practice must be shown to harm the entire industry, not just an individual, before it is deemed illegal. How can a practice ever be stopped before causing great harm if individuals cannot bring that charge? How will individual freedom be protected under such an “industry” standard? What freedom do we enjoy in this country that is not protected by our government? We need to work together to find that minimal, but effective government role. ...
Hopefully, future discussions will include admission from rule opponents that the continued presence of competition issues necessitates the need for reform. If they do not like the proposed GIPSA rule, what are their suggestions? Why do we not engage in a debate that recognizes “truth” in opposing views and seeks to develop solutions that will sustain our rural economies, positioning us to feed a hungry world?
Allan Sents serves as the U.S. Cattlemen’s Association marketing and competition chairman.
 

Your Opinions and Comments


Be the first to comment on this story!


You must be logged in to post a comment.




Not a subscriber?
Subscriber, but no password?
Forgot password?

Agriculture Today Archives


Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Floresville FFA teams state-bound (April 27, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Floresville FFA wins in Houston — livestock, judging, tractor restorations (April 27, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Hail damage may reduce harvest (April 27, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Karnes City Auction sale (April 27, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Land Stewardship produces a healthy Texas (April 27, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Livestock Market Reports (April 27, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Pesticide class set for May 16 (April 27, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. TDA Market Recap (April 27, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Texas Hay Report (April 27, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Ag program for military (April 20, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Benefit team roping in Jourdanton (April 20, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Bird feeding options (April 20, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Catfish management plan released (April 20, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. County 4-H’ers place in Houston (April 20, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Guada-Coma Chapter news (April 20, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Livestock Market Reports (April 20, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Regional conservation partnership (April 20, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. TDA Market Recap (April 20, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Texas Hay Report (April 20, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Youth Range Workshop (April 20, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Always follow label instructions (April 13, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Chemical collection is May 11 (April 13, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Livestock Market Reports (April 13, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Nixon-Smiley show produces champions (April 13, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. TDA Market Recap (April 13, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Texas Hay Report (April 13, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. East Central’s Patterson, Kempen, and poultry team win at SA show (April 6, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Livestock Market Reports (April 6, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Pruning without painting? (April 6, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. TDA Market Recap (April 6, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Texas Hay Report (April 6, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Tree grafting, pruning workshop (April 6, 2016)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Wilson County Spring Educational Program (April 6, 2016)
April 2016 Gardening Calendar (April 1, 2016)
Coupons ag-right
Allstate & McBride RealtyTriple R DC ExpertsVoncille Bielefeld homeHeavenly Touch homeEast Central Driving School

  Copyright © 2007-2016 Wilson County News. All rights reserved. Web development by Drewa Designs.