Monday, August 31, 2015
1012 C Street  •  Floresville, TX 78114  •  Phone: 830-216-4519  •  Fax: 830-393-3219  • 

WCN Site Search


Lost & Found


VideoLost Shih Tzu male-Golden Brown from CR 320 in Floresville If you have any information please call 210-452-1829 or 832-292-3305

VideoStill missing long hair chihuahua. Near 3rd and 97 please if you see her she is very missed. Call jeri 409-781-3191
*Includes FREE photo online! mywcn.com/lostandfound
More Lost & Found ads ›

Help Wanted

Caregivers needed. Call 830-431-2389. 
Sorting department for a local fundraising facility in La Vernia is hiring immediately. Apply in person 1371 FM 1346 La Vernia TX 78121
More Help Wanted ads ›

Featured Videos





Video Vault ›
TNMCRE/MAX homeRichardson Chevrolet home
You’ve been granted free access to this subscribers only article.

Section A: General News


Editorial: Whose welfare is it anyway?




E-Mail this Story to a Friend
Print this Story
Thomas Sowell
February 6, 2013 | 974 views | Post a comment

If there is ever a contest for the law with the most grossly misleading title, the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 should be a prime candidate, because the last thing this Act protects is the welfare of Indian children.

The theory behind the Indian Child Welfare Act is that an American Indian child should be raised in an American Indian culture.

Based on that theory, a newborn baby of American Indian ancestry, who was adopted immediately after birth by a white couple, was at 27 months of age taken away from the only parents she has ever known and given to her father.

Apparently the tribe has rights under the Indian Child Welfare Act. If this child were of any other race, a court would be free to decide the case on the basis of whatever was in the best interests of the child. Instead, the child is treated almost as property, contrary to the 13th Amendment that outlawed slavery.

Fortunately, the legal issues growing out of this case are now before the Supreme Court of the United States. We can only hope that the justices will use their wisdom, instead of their cleverness, to decide this case.

The Wisdom of Solomon provided a good example many centuries ago, in a case where two women each claimed to be the mother of a child and each demanded custody. Since he did not know who was the real mother, King Solomon said that he would cut the child in half and give each mother her half.

When one of the women dropped her claim, in order to spare the child’s life, he knew that she was the real mother. Anyone who would ruin a helpless child’s life, in order to assert their own legal prerogatives, or to protect the tribe’s turf, raises very serious questions about what kind of parent they are.

The question is not which home is better, but whether the child will ever feel secure in any home again, after the shock of being forcibly taken away.

The welfare of a flesh-and-blood human being should trump theories about cultures -- especially in the case of a two-year-old child, who has been torn away from the only parents she has ever known, and treated as a pawn in a legalistic game.

This little girl is just the latest in a long line of Indian children who have been ripped out of the only family they have ever known and given to someone who is a stranger to them, often living on an Indian reservation that is foreign to them. This has happened even to children who have spent a decade or more with a family to which they have become attached and is attached to them.

There have already been too many scenes of weeping and frightened children, crying out in vain for the only mother and father they have known, as they are forcibly dragged away.

Whatever the merits or demerits of various theories about culture, they are still just theories. But too many people put their pet theories ahead of flesh-and-blood human beings.

One of the rationales for the Indian Child Welfare Act is that, in the past, Indian children were wantonly wrested from their Indian parents and sent off to be raised by non-Indians. But nothing we can do today can undo the wrongs of the past -- especially not by creating the same wrongs again, in reverse.

While those who are most victimized by the so-called Indian Child Welfare Act are the children ripped out of their homes to satisfy some theory, they are not the only victims.

Indian children without biological parents to take care of them can be needlessly left in institutional care, when there are not enough Indian foster parents or adoptive parents to take them into their homes.

The Alice in Wonderland legal situation can hardly encourage non-Indian families to take care of these children, when that can so easily lead to heartbreak for both the children themselves and the surrogate parents who have become attached to them.

The New York Times reports that fewer than 2 percent of the children in Minnesota are Indian, but 15 percent of the children in that state’s foster care system are Indian. In Montana, 9 percent of the children are Indian, but Indian children make up 37 percent of the children in foster care.

What a price to pay for a theory!

Thomas Sowell is a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution, Stanford University. His website is http://www.tsowell.com.

Copyright 2012 creators.com.
 

Your Opinions and Comments


Be the first to comment on this story!


You must be logged in to post a comment.




Not a subscriber?
Subscriber, but no password?
Forgot password?

Section A: General News Archives


Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Cities grapple with eight-liner issues (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Connally Memorial to open two clinics in near future (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Council proposes no tax-rate increase (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Court Update (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Don't argue about it (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. DPS: Obey traffic laws, use extra caution as new school year begins (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Editorial: Mexico fears Trump candidacy (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Editorial: Peeking behind Walmart’s promise to invest in American jobs (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Editorial: Thoughts on Iran (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Extension agents resign (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Falls City ISD: tax rate to jump (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Five vie for three Floresville seats (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Floresville ISD says average taxpayer will save $61 (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Floresville offers concessions to landowners (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Floresville operations director will focus on public works (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Getting ab smart (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. La Vernia trustees OK lower tax rate (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Letter: It’s time to store the flag (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Letter: We’re not all complicit (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Lower tax rate, higher utility bills await Poth residents (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Meeting Watch: Floresville Parks Foundation (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Meeting Watch: Wilson County Commissioners Court (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Meeting Watch: Wilson County Emergency Services District No. 2 (Eagle Creek area) (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Pregnancy center comes to La Vernia (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Rainy weather contributes to myriad vehicle crashes (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Residents revive organization to beautify Wilson County (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Road Runners clear first hurdle to receive Floresville funds (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. SAPD officer dies in La Vernia (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Selling land the old-fashioned way (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Tips to make camping with your pet an exciting experience (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Veterans Career Fair is Sept. 3 (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Welcome back! (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. What do Floresville residents want in city parks? (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. ‘Pick It’ football contest (August 26, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Accident takes life of local teen (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Alamo Call-A-Ride 4 Vets program (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Chamber meeting set for Aug. 31 (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Community remembrance vigil for Chief Pimentel (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Crash injures Floresville woman (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Deadline Aug. 24 to get on November ballot (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Digital Marketing Boot Camp in SA (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Editorial: Christians’ denial keeps Planned Parenthood in business (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Editorial: Debate questions more like ‘gotcha’ rather then serious issues (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Editorial: It’s time to free students from higher-education debt (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Editorial: ‘Climate anger’: Last refuge of the green activists (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Elmendorf may cut tax rate (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Estate planning for landowners (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Formal ballet school takes shape in Wilson County (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Help police to ID suspect (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. La Vernia council approves Porter as new city secretary (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Letter: Disgruntled over FNES car-line changes (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Meeting Watch: Poth ISD board of trustees (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Meeting Watch: Stockdale EDC (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Meeting Watch: Wilson County Memorial Hospital District (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Meningitis vaccine required for college students (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Nehring turns herself in to authorities for livestock theft (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. No property tax-rate increase for Stockdale ISD residents, landowners (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Notes from the superintendent (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Officials work to ID burned body (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Oil and gas lease online sale nets $20M for public schools (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Otto Kaiser Memorial Hospital holds topping off celebration (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Police Blotter (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Roofing permit fee splits Floresville City Council members (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. St. Hedwig lowers tax rate (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Stockdale approves water resolution (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Tax increase possible for Stockdale-area emergency services (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. The best of three (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Workshop paves the way for better Floresville streets (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. ‘Meet the Teacher Night’ Aug. 20 (August 19, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. An analysis: Comment deadline nears for proposed water plans (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Burn ban back on for Wilson County (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Changes coming to Floresville streets (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Check out new LVISD app (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Christian Coalition hosts Bishop Williams (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Court Update (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. DA confirms Ortiz investigation (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Donate blood Aug. 18 (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Editorial: Could ‘The Donald’ be the Democrats Trump card? (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Editorial: Vote as I say, not as I do (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Editorial: We are at war! (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Feds offer $5M reward for ‘El Chapo’ arrest (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Floresville may sweeten agreement for annexation plan (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Floresville moves to streamline building permit process (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Floresville North new car-line procedures (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Floresville tackles employee sick leave (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Grants for nonprofits (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Kayak rescue (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Keeping Fido safe in the summer heat (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Letter: Healthcare foundation president thankful (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Letter: The good, bad effects of oil boom/bust (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Meeting Watch: China Grove City Council (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Meeting Watch: Floresville Economic Development Corp. (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Meeting Watch: Stockdale City Council (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Need a side income (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Oil slowdown spurs caution in budgeting for Poth EDC (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Police Blotter (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Police investigate suspicious activity (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Police seek four theft suspects (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Rangers arrest Nixon city manager (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Rangers search for suspected thief (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Sign up for vets job fair (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Stockdale council tables water opposition resolution (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Texas A&M honors John Burleson Sr. (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Thoughts on affordable housing, weatherization, traffic, more (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. What are ‘dog days’? (August 12, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Annexation baffles property owners (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. City manager discusses ‘Floresville effect,’ job, future (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Costlier health insurance hits Wilson County budget (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Cycle Ranch not ‘permanently closed’ (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Deadline to register for lay ministry program nears (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Dollar General to open north of Floresville (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Editorial: Documented irresponsibility (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Editorial: Doug Hughes: Protecting democracy from plutocrats (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Editorial: The media go gaga over certain political personalities (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Evergreen talks Cibolo Valley opposition (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. FEDC approves $10,000 for YMCA feasibility study (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. FELPS boss resigns (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. FELPS takes advantage of ‘Obamacare’ (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Fires scorch 80 acres (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Free wood chips (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Get your Feather Fest tickets (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Ice Cream Social is Aug. 14 (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. La Vernia housing plan gets OK (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Letter: I’m for Scott Walker (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Public invited to ‘Topping Out’ celebration (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Questions loom over Floresville’s annexation (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Region L mulls recycled wastewater proposal (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. RV park owner sues Floresville, city council, county appraisal district (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Texas VFW allays concerns (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Three new athletic directors usher in changes (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Trustees promote Pruitt (August 5, 2015)
Full article available to Wilson County News subscribers only. Click here to subscribe. Your wake-up call (August 5, 2015)