Wilson County News
Commentaries header
Wilson County News • 1012 C St • Floresville • TX • 78114 • Ph: 830-216-4519 • Fax: 830-393-3219 • Email:
Tuesday, Sep 2, 2014
Login
Not a subscriber? Click here.
Are you a WCN subscriber?
Set up your password.

 
E-Mail
Password
  Remember me
 
  Forgot password?
La Vernia News
Google
Google

Preview the Paper
Preview this week's Paper

Commentaries

School Vouchers a Bad Idea




E-Mail this Story to a Friend
Print this Story

Disclaimer:
The author of this entry is responsible for this content, which is not edited by the Wilson County News or wilsoncountynews.com.
February 22, 2013 | 4116 views | 12 comments

By Eric Lane

Do we want to support and improve our public schools or do we want to dismantle them? That is the question. At least that is the question school vouchers force us to confront. To answer this question we need to be honest. We must begin by acknowledging that vouchers do nothing to improve public education. They do just the opposite. Vouchers drain badly needed money from already underfunded public schools, public schools that today educate almost ninety percent of all American children K-12.

Supporters argue that vouchers offer ‘choice’ and ‘competition.’ This simply is not true. Private schools educate about ten percent of K-12 students in this country. Since almost all private schools are religious schools, the only so-called ‘choice’ vouchers offer is between a public education and a private, religious education. Is this real ‘choice’ or is this a backdoor way for the government to subsidize primarily private, religious schools? You decide.

‘Choice’ has other serious problems that we need to consider.
For example, vouchers undermine religious liberty. They force Americans to pay taxes to support religious schools they may find disagreeable or even objectionable with their own religious or philosophical beliefs. This runs counter to the First Amendment’s guarantee of religious liberty. In America, all religious activities should be supported with voluntary contributions, not tax money. Why?

The Founders were unyielding in their support of separation of church and state and strongly opposed taxation to bolster any religion. This was not because they were anti-religious. Ben Franklin may have said it best: “When a religion is good, I conceive it will support itself; and when it does not support itself, and God does not care to support it, so that its professors are obliged to call for the help of civil power, ‘tis a sign, I apprehend, of its being a bad one.”

Less understood is how vouchers present a serious threat to the independence of religious institutions and schools.

Separation of church and state is a two-way road. Not only does it keep religion out of government affairs, it keeps government out of religious affairs as well. Taking government money may sound good at first but it is really a Faustian bargain. Government money ultimately means government control.

Taking government money to support religious schools will inevitably bring unwelcome government intrusion. It will bring a growing dependence on government largess and the political winds that come and go. And potentially, it will mean fundamental government involvement in church affairs, a clear violation of church and state separation.

Supporters of vouchers also speak of the magic of the market and the benefits of ‘competition.’ But what competition are they talking about? If by ‘competition’ they mean different faith traditions will be competing for students, how many parents will allow their children to go to schools that preach different faith traditions than their own? I would argue not many.

Maybe, by ‘competition,’ pro-voucher folks mean that sometime in the future Wall Street and hedge fund managers will use voucher money to open up private, unaccountable, corporate run schools whose first responsibility will be to return profits to their stockholders. What could go wrong here?

Let’s remember that under most voucher plans, private schools can deny admission to any student they choose. Public schools cannot. Private schools can discriminate against students based on religion, disability, economic background, academic record, English language proficiency, disciplinary history and other criteria. Public schools cannot. Private schools can ‘skim’ the cream. Public schools cannot.

According to multiple studies of the District of Colombia, Milwaukee and Cleveland, school voucher programs have not improved student academic performance. Vouchers have also done little to help low-income students because payments often do not cover the entire cost of tuition and other fees, including the cost of transportation to schools that can be many miles away. In actuality, vouchers harm poor student’s education by undermining the public schools upon which they rely.

It is illogical to believe that we can take money out of the public school system and improve education, especially in our inner cities. But this is what voucher supporters are advocating.

Our public school system made the United States the preeminent nation of the 20th and the first part of the 21st Century. Why would we replace such a successful school system with private religious schools or an untested, profit driven, and corporate education model? They would seem to be a recipe for disaster. We do need to decide.

Eric Lane is President of the San Antonio Chapter of Americans United for Separation of Church & State. He can be contacted at ausa.president@americansunitedsa.org
 
« Previous Blog Entry (February 21, 2013)
 


Your Opinions and Comments
 
Well Alrighty Then  
San Antonio  
February 27, 2013 3:42pm
 
 
I think they are a great idea. Maybe then our public school system will sit up and take notice.
 
 
4 th Generation Texan  
Sutherland Springs  
February 26, 2013 1:21pm
 
 
School vouchers are a bad idea for 'bad schools'. With vouchers, bad schools would either get better or they would close down. Sounds like something based on the way ... Read More Read More
 
 
BSP  
Floresville  
February 25, 2013 1:33pm
 
 
.... "Taking government money to support religious schools will inevitably bring unwelcome government intrusion". .... Taking my money to fund designated public ... Read More Read More
 
 
Be Careful  
Floresville, TX  
February 25, 2013 1:29pm
 
 
Eric you need to be honest. You don’t use facts but rather make blanket false statements. Eric you said, “we need to be honest. We must begin by acknowledging that vouchers ... Read More Read More
 
 
Alvin Charmaine  
February 24, 2013 4:10pm
 
 
I think school vouchers would be outstanding, I think if familes want to home school they should keep the money. That right there is the one sure way to acheive the best ... Read More Read More
 
 
PRAIRIE GROUCH  
GRAND PRAIRIE TX  
February 24, 2013 10:09am
 
 
In reference to the private religious schools, the
main obstacle to being able to fill the void is not
the quality of the instruction but the number and
size of the facilities. ... Read More Read More
 
 
Elaine K.  
Floresville  
February 24, 2013 9:05am
 
 
Agree with Prairie. But would add that private religious schools can go a long way toward providing that quality education if they just had a bit of an easier time. We just ... Read More Read More
 
 
PRAIRIE GROUCH  
GRAND PRAIRIE TX  
February 24, 2013 8:47am
 
 
According to a WAPO article listing the top twenty
schools in the nation, Texas is home to seven of
those schools. Of the seven, four are charter schools
Another one ... Read More Read More
 
 
Elaine K.  
Floresville  
February 23, 2013 9:48am
 
 
Texans speak out for school choice. Video posted by Americans for Prosperity: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O49PwEEgL9k&feature=youtu.be
 
 
PRAIRIE GROUCH  
GRAND PRAIRIE TX  
February 23, 2013 6:45am
 
 
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment
of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof;
................................................
...........

Liberals ... Read More Read More
 

Share your comment or opinion on this story!


You must be logged in to post comments:



Other Commentaries



Commentaries


Commentaries page govtrack.us
Commentaries who represents me?
 
^Top
  Copyright © 2014 Wilson County News. All rights reserved. Web development by Drewa Designs.
^Top