You’ve been granted free access to this subscribers only article.
Editorial: Pick one: Fear of violence or the right of liberty, property
Guest EditorialJuly 10, 2013 | 1,553 views | 1 comment
By Tim McGowan
Re: “Little cities v. federal law” July 3
In his letter to the editor, Mr. Szalwinski uses language that infers or directly asserts four points. The simple answer to his questions and assertion is found in what Dr. Brumlow wrote in his letter on July 3: How we make decisions is a moral question.
Mr. Szalwinski said if all three branches of the U.S. federal system approve a law limiting all firearms to a capacity of 10 rounds, that federal law overrules city or state law.
After a lengthy search of articles and court rulings, I present for readers this excerpt from an article by Michael Doyle, McClatchy Newspapers, Dec. 9, 2012. For the most part, Mr. Doyle characterizes the current status of Second Amendment questions.
“Some state and local gun-control measures already have died over the past four and a half years, done in by the high court’s 2008 ruling that recognized expansive constitutional protections for firearm ownership. Similar Second Amendment restraints will limit the ambitions of the Obama gun task force and its Capitol Hill counterparts.
“The Supreme Court has decided that the amendment confers a right to bear arms for self-defense, which is as important outside the home as inside,” Judge Richard Posner of the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals noted in a ruling last week [Dec. 2012].
“Some additional gun restrictions, however, certainly will survive legal challenge. The Supreme Court has said that “laws imposing conditions and qualifications” on firearms sales may be permitted. This might allow, for instance, more background-check requirements. The court further indicated in 2008 that ‘an important limitation on the right to keep and carry arms’ extends to ‘dangerous and unusual weapons.’
“That might include military firearms such as the M16 assault rifle, which the Supreme Court specifically cited. Adam Lanza, who killed 20 children and six women ... at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Conn., used a Bushmaster AR-15-style rifle, a civilian version of the M16.
“The Supreme Court’s 2008 decision, however, has confining power. Posner’s ruling ... underscored that. His opinion struck down an Illinois law that prohibited most individuals from carrying firearms in public.
“‘The prohibition of semi-automatic rifles and large-capacity magazines does not effectively disarm individuals or substantially affect their ability to defend themselves,’ said Judge Douglas Ginsburg, who was appointed by President Ronald Reagan.”
Mr. Szalwinski also stated that the latest polls show that about 90 percent of Americans want stronger background checks.
This was a three-state poll of Virginia, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania in January 2013, just a month after the Sandy Hook Elementary school shooting. Support for background checks has dipped nationally but remains strong, according to a poll by the Democratic-affiliated Public Policy Polling, set for release Tuesday. The finding, shared in advance with TPM, was that 73 percent of registered American voters support “requiring background checks for all gun sales, including gun shows and the internet,” while 21 percent oppose it.
According to Mr. Szalwinski, the U.S. Founders did not intend for everyone to have the right to large assault-type weapons with magazine capacity of 100 rounds.
Amendment II of the U.S. Constitution is unique among constitutions and governmental compacts in that it clearly places the means to threaten tyranny in the hands of the people and is stated without restriction. It is also the hand-in-glove guardian of the First Amendment.
The very simple and direct language of the Second Amendment is the relevant point of discussion “... the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.” I pose there is only one way to read this clause in English: Anyone of legal stature can own and use any type of arm they can buy or build. This broad, but distinctly definitive statement is many times argued to only apply to self-defense or hunting. Self-defense and hunting are not discussed in the Second Amendment or in the Federalist or Anti-Federalist Papers. The arms held by the common people in 1776 were on par or better than what the common soldier was issued. Capability of arms held by the people was based on what the individual could afford.
We don’t have to attempt to read the intent of the Founders; they wrote it down. Our essential task is: To whom much is given, much is expected. The common man and the government are expected to not conduct undue violent acts on our fellow man. Undue violence must be punished, the innocent must maintain their inalienable right to keep and bear arms.
Restricting access to arms is not specified nor implied within the U.S. Constitution; that idea came later and finds its origin in the Dred Scott decision. Over time, the adversaries of arms ownership by the people artfully crafted law to include “common use” test of access to arms of any type. This idea of “common use” is a legal term of art, which is the proverbial camel’s nose under the tent. From the assertion that arms available for the people are separate and distinct from those available to the government, we then move the control of all coercive force to the government. Exclusive access to arms held by a government is a key indicator of a totalitarian state. Registration of arms and users of arms is the key step to confiscation.
Bad law and philosophy has undermined the origin of the ideas which formed this country. These erosions of the original idea of America are making our future historically recognizable and very negative.
Bravo to Falls City, Poth, the vast number of U.S. sheriffs, the Maryland Fraternal Order of Police, the Australian, Israeli, Swiss people, Oathkeepers, and other liberty-minded people who stand for the inalienable right for persons of legal stature to own and use arms. Go Falls City and Poth! Take on the continuing assault on property rights of U.S. persons.
The argument of arms ownership in this country is not new. Current era debates of arms ownership are highly influenced by the trauma of attacks on the innocent. When discussing violent acts we must use the presumption of innocence, for we the people as a common element for both sides of this emotionally charged topic. At the same time, the penalty for the violent criminals must be so harsh and definitive that those who would commit violent crime are permanently unable to repeat their violence.
Depending which study is referenced, violent crime prevention in the United States by the use of firearms ranges from 800,000 up to 2 million times annually -- more than 100 times the number of murders committed with a firearm. This estimate is broad, due to the terms used in law-enforcement reporting.
The origin of attacks on the seemingly innocent is a moral question of what is in the heart of man. When we disconnect ourselves from the origin of moral authority, we choose situational ethics and are able to reconcile any behavior or statement we make; we justify doing bad things.
The discussion of crime control must be an active point of why arms ownership is essential; we must reject the unthoughtful attacks on the innocent, common citizens’ capacity to defend ourselves and threaten tyranny. Access to arms must be unfettered and open to all lawful U.S. persons. The question of mental health is also important, but must be carefully considered as it can be used to falsely classify people and become a tool of oppression.
When a government through artful language restricts an inalienable right, what is that government? Laws passed which violate the Constitution are not lawful. The nullification of that bad law is the responsibility of we the people.
“When the people fear their government, there is tyranny; when the government fears the people, there is liberty.” -- Thomas Jefferson
Tim McGowan is a resident of Floresville.
Your Opinions and Comments
Publius Valerius Publicola
July 11, 2013 2:20pm
Share your comment or opinion on this story!
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Section A: General News Archives
Alamo Memorial Day established (November 25, 2015)
Daughters of the Republic take a stand for Alamo artifacts, library collection (November 25, 2015)
Editorial: Are we ignoring the obvious? (November 25, 2015)
Editorial: Main Street vs. Black Friday and Small Biz Saturday (November 25, 2015)
Falls City group honored with STEER award (November 25, 2015)
Is it really necessary to walk 10,000 steps? (November 25, 2015)
Letter: Message to anti-gun lobby (November 25, 2015)
Letter: One view of new council (November 25, 2015)
Letter: Why can’t the mayor and council get along? (November 25, 2015)
Letter: Why skip the turkey on Thanksgiving? (November 25, 2015)
Obama denies Keystone connection from Canada to Texas (November 25, 2015)
Paper Clover Campaign raises funds for 4-H youth (November 25, 2015)
A hiring predicament (November 18, 2015)
Building a strong foundation (November 18, 2015)
Camino Real to open Lytle crisis center Dec. 7 (November 18, 2015)
City looks to cut ties with SAWS (November 18, 2015)
Closures, detours for Elmendorf roads (November 18, 2015)
County appraisal district soldiers on (November 18, 2015)
Court Update (November 18, 2015)
Early-shift employee finds front-row view of tornado (November 18, 2015)
Editorial: When, if ever, will we close America’s borders? (November 18, 2015)
Elmendorf could have sales-tax vote (November 18, 2015)
Enjoy an evening with Santa Dec. 5 (November 18, 2015)
Enjoy Thanksgiving Dinner Nov. 22 (November 18, 2015)
FEDC invites your opinion on city parks (November 18, 2015)
File by Dec. 14 for March 1 primary (November 18, 2015)
Fill boxes for Operation Christmas Child (November 18, 2015)
Floresville proves its mettle after tornado leaves mark (November 18, 2015)
Free family movie Nov. 24 (November 18, 2015)
Get ACA enrollment assistance at library (November 18, 2015)
Give thanks at service (November 18, 2015)
Help for owners with storm damages (November 18, 2015)
Honoring our veterans (November 18, 2015)
LED lights could save Poth ISD $5K per year (November 18, 2015)
Letter: Gratitude for Stockdale’s Veterans Day program (November 18, 2015)
Letter: It’s real and it is happening now (November 18, 2015)
Letter: Leave it local (November 18, 2015)
Letter: Questions for Clinton (November 18, 2015)
Letter: Senseless tragedy in Paris (November 18, 2015)
Letter: Who should get credit for school song? (November 18, 2015)
Meeting Watch: La Vernia City Council (November 18, 2015)
Meeting Watch: Sandy Oaks City Council (November 18, 2015)
Meeting Watch: Stockdale ISD (November 18, 2015)
New council majority names mayor (November 18, 2015)
P&Z approves game room rules (November 18, 2015)
Peanut Fest designers needed (November 18, 2015)
San Antonio River study takes flight (November 18, 2015)
SARA to hold environmental meeting Nov. 20 (November 18, 2015)
Southwest General receives award for stroke prevention (November 18, 2015)
Stockdale council ‘lights’ the way for safety concerns (November 18, 2015)
Student’s faith unites community (November 18, 2015)
Take part in holiday decorating contest (November 18, 2015)
Watch D.O.G.S. pizza night (November 18, 2015)
‘Thanks to everyone, we’re moving forward to rebuild’ (November 18, 2015)
4-H Club Food Drive is Nov. 14 (November 11, 2015)
Area lawmen continue to crack down on gambling (November 11, 2015)
Basketball coach recounts his tornado survival story (November 11, 2015)
Beautification group to meet (November 11, 2015)
Business continues despite twister (November 11, 2015)
Changes at State Veteran Cemeteries (November 11, 2015)
China Grove names council member, alternate judge (November 11, 2015)
Connally clinic plans Nov. 13 open house (November 11, 2015)
Court Update (November 11, 2015)
Cuellar comments on Obama’s veto of Keystone pipeline (November 11, 2015)
Deadline is Nov. 24 to order wreaths for fallen military (November 11, 2015)
District 3 EMS helps triage after Floresville tornado (November 11, 2015)
Doing the right thing (November 11, 2015)
Drama Kids honor Detamore (November 11, 2015)
Editorial: Teapot tempest: Media buzz about Carson’s credibility (November 11, 2015)
Expert offers tips to end tobacco habit (November 11, 2015)
Family violence: What can victims do? (November 11, 2015)
Free transportation for vets (November 11, 2015)
Funds available for warning system, home repairs (November 11, 2015)
Groundwater Management Area 13 meeting Nov. 19 (November 11, 2015)
Hospital, senior-care centers go into emergency mode (November 11, 2015)
How you can help (November 11, 2015)
Lazy J cook weathers storm in cooler (November 11, 2015)
Letter: Gratitude to volunteers who chose decency over ‘cashing in’ (November 11, 2015)
Letter: Hometown newspapers to be valued (November 11, 2015)
Letter: Honored to have served St. Hedwig (November 11, 2015)
Meeting Watch: Evergreen Underground Water Conservation District (November 11, 2015)
Meeting Watch: Floresville 4A Corp. (November 11, 2015)
Meeting Watch: La Vernia ISD (November 11, 2015)
Meeting Watch: Wilson County Commissioners Court (November 11, 2015)
New book reveals Longhorn legend (November 11, 2015)
Nieto wins re-election, all seven propositions pass (November 11, 2015)
November offers opportunities to donate blood (November 11, 2015)
Officials investigate three fatal crashes (November 11, 2015)
Planning for growth in La Vernia ISD (November 11, 2015)
Special showing of ‘Silent Conquest’ (November 11, 2015)
St. Hedwig ‘seals’ its history with new symbol (November 11, 2015)
The positive force of prayer makes #FloresvilleStrong (November 11, 2015)
Veterans job fair (November 11, 2015)
Allen West: America needs leadership (November 4, 2015)
Bexar County Sheriff’s Office releases app (November 4, 2015)
Business receives solar grant (November 4, 2015)
Businesses begin effort to pick up the pieces (November 4, 2015)
Celebrate Veterans Day (November 4, 2015)
Community comes together for Floresville storm recovery (November 4, 2015)
Contents of buried fridge spook bulldozer operator in Elmendorf (November 4, 2015)
Council approves WOAI promotions (November 4, 2015)
Deputies say woman torched house (November 4, 2015)
Despite power outage, voting goes on (November 4, 2015)
Disaster loans for small businesses (November 4, 2015)
Editorial: Congress’s problems are deep-seated but fixable (November 4, 2015)
Editorial: Open season on the police (November 4, 2015)
Editorial: We are #FloresvilleStrong — as we recover and rebuild (November 4, 2015)
Emergency district to address water (November 4, 2015)
Family survives as twister devastates home (November 4, 2015)
FELPS brings region out of the dark (November 4, 2015)
Game wardens stop poaching rampage (November 4, 2015)
Happening today: Veterans fest to benefit Wounded Warriors (November 4, 2015)
High school students to return Nov. 6 (November 4, 2015)
Holmes Foods is recipient of $69K (November 4, 2015)
How to be #FloresvilleStrong (November 4, 2015)
Lawmen perform active-shooter drill (November 4, 2015)
Letter: Making a difference (November 4, 2015)
Letter: Property owners already feeling the pinch of Proposition I (November 4, 2015)
Make the decision with her (November 4, 2015)
Meeting Watch: Floresville Electric Light & Power System (November 4, 2015)
Meeting Watch: Wilson County Commissioners Court (November 4, 2015)
Nixon-Smiley Ranch Rodeo (November 4, 2015)
Police Blotter (November 4, 2015)
Praying for Floresville (November 4, 2015)
Pruski is among top area agents (November 4, 2015)
Ranch Rodeo opening ceremony (November 4, 2015)
Sheriff Santa program hosts annual event (November 4, 2015)
TCEQ plans water meeting (November 4, 2015)
Tornado doesn’t stop tax payments (November 4, 2015)
Tornado hits Floresville (November 4, 2015)