You’ve been granted free access to this subscribers only article.
Editorial: Americans know very little about local school quality
By J.E. Stone
A cheating scandal involving teachers in Atlanta has captured national attention and revealed a profound breach of trust in the public education system.
Thirty-five area educators, including some principals, have been accused of falsifying student test scores and now stand charged with racketeering, theft, and making false statements to law enforcement.
Apologists blame their actions on excessive testing, but that’s like blaming a banking scandal on the auditors. Instead of worrying about fairness for the adults, we should be worrying about these children and their futures.
Many will receive a shockingly poor education, leaving them little hope of earning a family-sustaining wage once they enter the work force.
How could a scam this massive take place under everyone’s nose? Clearly, Atlanta has a problem. But this is just a highly visible instance of a much larger problem. Average Americans actually know very little about the quality of their local schools. Despite the obvious conflict of interest, most people simply accept the soothing reassurances of the schools themselves.
That’s a problem. The only way to actually improve educational outcomes is for parents and local boards to hold schools accountable. And to do that, they need accurate information about student achievement, budgets, program effectiveness, and the like.
But right now, all across the country, parents and local boards are being kept in the dark about such essential matters. Even where there has not been outright cheating as in Atlanta, the information furnished by districts is typically slanted or outright misleading. Successes are hyped, failures rationalized, and statistics are reported with skimpy context.
It’s no secret that too many students aren’t learning. Today, only about 30 percent of children can read at grade level by the third grade. For low-income students, an astounding 83 percent of students fail to meet this mark. And half of the U.S. work force -- about 80 million adults -- lack the educational skills necessary to earn a family-sustaining wage. The future is in jeopardy.
To get a sense of the problem, consider the differences between the scores reported by the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) and those reported by the states.
Congress created NAEP in 1988 to independently measure national student achievement on a variety of subjects for the Department of Education. Today, it’s considered the gold standard of educational assessment for critical subjects like math, reading, science, and writing.
States, of course, also have their own metrics. The differences are stark and embarrassing.
For instance, the Alabama Department of Education claims 80 percent of its fourth-grade students are proficient in math. According to the NAEP, only 30 percent are actually proficient.
Alabama isn’t unique. Scores are just as inflated in neighboring Georgia -- and that’s in addition to distortions caused by Atlanta’s cheating. The state says over 80 percent are proficient in math, but the NAEP says 40 percent is closer to reality. But wait, there’s more! Much more.
The Maryland Department of Education claims 90 percent of its students are proficient in fourth-grade math. NAEP says it’s closer to 50 percent. California’s Education Department says six in 10 eighth-graders are proficient in science. NAEP’s assessment? Barely above 20 percent. Most states follow this pattern.
As a result of these reporting gaps, parents and board members generally believe their local schools are better than they actually are. And those that do sense problems tend to assume that money will solve them.
But decades of increased funding has produced little improvement. Since the 1970s, the NAEP reports that achievement in core subjects like reading and math has remained stagnant. In fact, constant-dollar per-pupil expenditures doubled between 1971 and 2009, yet reading scores didn’t budge.
In a global economy, the United States will inevitably sink unless parents, school boards, and educators are able to confront the facts, warts and all, but educators fear exposure.
Fortunately, there are sound data out there. Parents don’t have to wait for distant bureaucrats to tinker their way to trustworthy school reports. Right now, they can find detailed report cards at greatschools.org and schooldigger.com.
The Education Consumers Foundation, displays school-by-school data online in easy-to-understand graphics for virtually all states.
These are just a few of the resources available to parents, boards, and community leaders who want to look beyond inflated self-reports and into the facts that can lead to real school improvement.
J.E. Stone is president and CEO of Education Consumers Foundation.
Your Opinions and Comments
7th Generation La Vernian
August 28, 2013 1:56pm
Publius Valerius Publicola
August 28, 2013 12:51pm
Share your comment or opinion on this story!
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Section A: General News Archives
City says no more streetlights (October 7, 2015)
CMMC offers low cost mammograms (October 7, 2015)
County judge invites taxpayers to Town Hall (October 7, 2015)
Court Update (October 7, 2015)
Crosscurrents characterize city session (October 7, 2015)
Deputies charge game-room owners (October 7, 2015)
Does the right to collect still exist? (October 7, 2015)
Early detection vital to treating breast cancer (October 7, 2015)
Editorial: Challenges of democracy (October 7, 2015)
Editorial: Do not kill police officers, black people, white people, or any people (October 7, 2015)
Editorial: Good riddance, John Boehner! (October 7, 2015)
Editorial: President Obama once again too quick to ‘jump the gun’ (October 7, 2015)
Feather Fest 5K walk/run winners (October 7, 2015)
FELPS estimates near $1M savings after refinancing ’02, ’05 bonds (October 7, 2015)
Going hog wild with cook-off, ranch rodeo (October 7, 2015)
Health options workshop is Oct.13 (October 7, 2015)
La Vernia EMS president: Let’s train together (October 7, 2015)
Laubach Cemetery group plans meeting (October 7, 2015)
Letter: Seeking De La Peña family photos (October 7, 2015)
Luther Thomas Elementary earns Blue Ribbon status (October 7, 2015)
Meeting Watch: China Grove City Council (October 7, 2015)
Meeting Watch: Falls City ISD (October 7, 2015)
Meeting Watch: Floresville 4A Corp. (October 7, 2015)
Paxton: Attorney misled immigrants (October 7, 2015)
Pilot digital photography workshops coming to parks (October 7, 2015)
Police Blotter (October 7, 2015)
Texas A&M-San Antonio opens to freshmen Oct. 1 (October 7, 2015)
Texas secures highest credit ratings (October 7, 2015)
Water rules affect all Texans (October 7, 2015)
West Nile survivor shares story of recovery (October 7, 2015)