You’ve been granted free access to this subscribers only article.
Editorial: Ideology of victimhood may explain disparity
Depressing news about black students scoring far below white students on various mental tests has become so familiar that people in different parts of the ideological spectrum have long ago developed their different explanations for why this is so. But both may have to do some rethinking, in light of radically different news from England.
The November 9th-15th issue of the distinguished British magazine The Economist reports that, among children who are eligible for free meals in England’s schools, black children of immigrants from Africa meet the standards of school tests nearly 60 percent of the time -- as do immigrant children from Bangladesh and Pakistan. Black children of immigrants from the Caribbean meet the standards less than 50 percent of the time.
At the bottom, among those children who are all from families with low enough incomes to receive free meals at school, are white English children, who meet the standards 30 percent of the time.
The Economist points out that, in one borough of London, white students scored lower than black students in any London borough.
These data might seem to be some kind of fluke, but they confirm the observations in a book titled Life at the Bottom by British physician Theodore Dalrymple. He said that, among the patients he treated in a hospital near a low-income housing project, he could not recall any white 16-year-old who could multiply nine by seven. Some could not even do three times seven.
What jolts us is not only that this phenomenon is so different from what we are used to seeing in the United States, but also that it fits neither the genetic nor the environmental explanation of black-white educational differences here.
These white students in England come from the same race that produced Shakespeare and the great scientist Sir Isaac Newton, among other world-class intellects over the centuries. But today many young whites in England are barely literate, and have trouble with simple arithmetic. Nor are these white students the victims of racial discrimination, much less the descendants of slaves.
With the two main explanations for low performances on school tests obviously not applicable in England, there must be some other explanation. And once there is some other explanation in this case, we have to wonder if that other explanation -- whatever it is -- might also apply in the United States, to one degree or another.
In other words, maybe our own explanations need reexamination.
What do low-income whites in England and ghetto blacks in the United States have in common? It cannot be simply low incomes, because children from other groups in the same low-income brackets out perform whites in England and out perform blacks in America.
What low-income whites in England and ghetto blacks in the United States have in common is a generations-long indoctrination in victimhood. The political left in both countries has, for more than half a century, maintained a steady and loud drumbeat of claims that the deck is stacked against those at the bottom.
The American left uses race and the British left uses class, but the British left has been at it longer. In both countries, immigrants who have not been in the country as long have not been so distracted by such ideology into a blind resentment and lashing out at other people.
In both countries, immigrants enter a supposedly closed society that refuses to let anyone rise -- and they nevertheless rise, while the native-born at the bottom remain at the bottom.
Those who promote an ideology of victimhood may imagine that they are helping those at the bottom, when in fact they are harming them, more so than the society that the left is denouncing.
We in America have gotten used to vast gaps between blacks and whites on test scores. But this was not always the case, in places where there was anything like comparable education.
Back in the 1940s, before the vast expansion of the welfare state and the ideology of victimhood used to justify it, there was no such gap on test scores between black schools in Harlem and white, working class schools on New York’s lower east side.
You can find the data on pages 40-41 of an article of mine in the fall 1981 issue of Teachers College Record, a journal published by Columbia University -- that is, if you think facts matter more than rhetoric or social visions.
Thomas Sowell is a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution, Stanford University. His website is http://www.tsowell.com.
Copyright 2013 creators.com
Your Opinions and Comments
Be the first to comment on this story!
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Section A: General News Archives
Attend Health Fair in Seguin July 29 (July 22, 2015)
Crash near county line claims one (July 22, 2015)
ECISD gives raises, keeps tax rate same (July 22, 2015)
Editorial: Choose carefully where to invest your energy (July 22, 2015)
Editorial: Government for Big Money (July 22, 2015)
Editorial: Is the Civil War over? (July 22, 2015)
Editorial: It’s time to take a stand in defense of liberty (July 22, 2015)
Emergency services directors review OT costs, reduce fleet (July 22, 2015)
Fox Chapel continues SEDC payments (July 22, 2015)
Franchise Ownership Workshop July 25 (July 22, 2015)
Goody bag items needed for chamber (July 22, 2015)
Hospital district approves adding new medical staff (July 22, 2015)
Jade Helm 15 military exercises under way (July 22, 2015)
Jason Talley to lead state organization (July 22, 2015)
Keeping Floresville in style for 25 years (July 22, 2015)
La Vernia area could combine paid, volunteer fire staff (July 22, 2015)
Meeting Watch: Falls City City Council (July 22, 2015)
Meeting Watch: Falls City ISD (July 22, 2015)
Meeting Watch: La Vernia ISD (July 22, 2015)
Obamacare increases starting pay for food-service staff Stockdale ISD (July 22, 2015)
Paying ‘stupid tax’ (July 22, 2015)
Police Blotter (July 22, 2015)
Police seek three suspects for theft (July 22, 2015)
Poth ISD board gets first glimpse of 2015-16 budget (July 22, 2015)
UIW to bring holistic healing to SA’s south side (July 22, 2015)
Bealls participates in clothing drive (July 15, 2015)
Beautification group to meet (July 15, 2015)
CoDA finds source of anxious behavior (July 15, 2015)
Commissioners grant waiver to Mission Rail Industrial Park (July 15, 2015)
Editorial: Americans’ focus is on anything but serious issues (July 15, 2015)
Editorial: Looking back on my 85 years (July 15, 2015)
Editorial: Surprise! Scientists have ‘cracked code’ to happiness (July 15, 2015)
Elmendorf council votes 4-1 to abolish ‘assistant city administrator’ post (July 15, 2015)
Elmendorf, SAWS reach deal (July 15, 2015)
FEMA seeks Texans to work at disaster recovery offices (July 15, 2015)
Floresville joins opposition to water transport project (July 15, 2015)
Floresville Visitor & Tourist Bureau takes small steps (July 15, 2015)
La Vernia council remains as MDD board (July 15, 2015)
La Vernia council terminates city secretary (July 15, 2015)
Letter: Let’s get involved (July 15, 2015)
Managing growth, groundwater responsibly — an analysis of water ‘surplus’ project (July 15, 2015)
Meet DPS Sgt. John Henke (July 15, 2015)
Meeting Watch: La Vernia City Council (July 15, 2015)
No lease: Floresville 4A Corp. applies for beer license (July 15, 2015)
No quorum for Poth EDC (July 15, 2015)
Otto Kaiser plans health fair, low-cost physicals (July 15, 2015)
Police blotter (July 15, 2015)
Questions remain after reported attack (July 15, 2015)
Reputed dope dealer takes plea (July 15, 2015)
Saenz interns with Cuellar (July 15, 2015)
STEER calls for award nominations (July 15, 2015)
Stockdale News: Giving Jubilee kudos (July 15, 2015)
Stockdale News: Leos to hold yard sale (July 15, 2015)
Stockdale News: Library fun continues (July 15, 2015)
Stockdale News: Mitchell places in top 10 of national rifle competition (July 15, 2015)
Stockdale to receive $311K in grant, earnings distribution (July 15, 2015)
Texas A&M to pair with two-year colleges (July 15, 2015)
Unauthorized subletting (July 15, 2015)
Veterans eligible for VA Medical Care (July 15, 2015)
Winter rainfall dries up city’s utilities income (July 15, 2015)
World Heritage Site designation piques curiosity in ranch (July 15, 2015)
ADCaP, UIW online fall information session is July 9 (July 8, 2015)
Avoid skin cancer; protect your family from the summer sun (July 8, 2015)
Chief appraiser’s opening draws four applications (July 8, 2015)
Connally donates to Floresville Food Pantry (July 8, 2015)
Court Update (July 8, 2015)
Dangers of leaving children in vehicles during summer (July 8, 2015)
Deel named top 10 advisor, inducted into Hall of Fame (July 8, 2015)
Does the YMCA have a future in Wilson County? (July 8, 2015)
Editorial: Guns in church can work (July 8, 2015)
Editorial: U.S. Supreme Court disasters (July 8, 2015)
Evergreen states opposition to Cibolo, Schertz water plan (July 8, 2015)
Floresville Economic Development Corp. (July 8, 2015)
Floresville Planning & Zoning Commission (July 8, 2015)
Floresville police hunt suspects, arrest two (July 8, 2015)
Home safety while you’re away (July 8, 2015)
Host an exchange student (July 8, 2015)
How to handle difficult discussions in the workplace (July 8, 2015)
Letter: A third letter to America (July 8, 2015)
Letter: Hoping to find the cowardly culprit (July 8, 2015)
Letter: No press coverage, no tickets (July 8, 2015)
Meeting Watch: Poth ISD (July 8, 2015)
Museum seeks lumber, pictures (July 8, 2015)
Nominate your 2015 favorite country doctor (July 8, 2015)
Nonprofits encouraged to partake in Newcomers Fair (July 8, 2015)
Parking garage at SA airport to close (July 8, 2015)
Pause investing for a luxury (July 8, 2015)
Police Blotter (July 8, 2015)
Poth cancels another city council meeting (July 8, 2015)
Poth, Stockdale could get Connally Memorial clinics (July 8, 2015)
Rancho de las Cabras achieves World status (July 8, 2015)
Shooting range drives citizens to City Hall (July 8, 2015)
SSCA to meet (July 8, 2015)
St. Hedwig City Council backs off fire-code variance (July 8, 2015)
Texas sues EPA (July 8, 2015)
Trustees approve $9.55 million budget (July 8, 2015)
Yoga Center marks one year (July 8, 2015)
Corner Store grand opening is set for July 2 (July 1, 2015)
Court Update (July 1, 2015)
Crouch Memorial Bull Riding (July 1, 2015)
Dan Patrick weighs in on same-sex marriage decision (July 1, 2015)
Disabled veteran license plates available for widows (July 1, 2015)
Does the EPA control your stock tank? (July 1, 2015)
East Central ISD decisions will save taxpayers millions (July 1, 2015)
Editorial: Changing the past to fundamentally transform America (July 1, 2015)
Editorial: Donald Trump tries to put his brand on GOP (July 1, 2015)
Editorial: Hillary and history: Best-known is not the same as best-qualified (July 1, 2015)
Event highlights seniors, vets, services July 17 (July 1, 2015)
FELPS aims to improve reliability systemwide (July 1, 2015)
Floresville ISD adopts $39M budget (July 1, 2015)
Floresville keeps city manager, 'extravaganza' (July 1, 2015)
Free July training for business owners (July 1, 2015)
Guadalupe deputies hunt fugitive after bar fight near Seguin (July 1, 2015)
H-E-B recalls burger buns (July 1, 2015)
La Vernia approves $26M-plus budget (July 1, 2015)
Letter: Frightened aging bones (July 1, 2015)
Meeting Watch: Falls City City Council (July 1, 2015)
Miles Svoboda earns saddle in chute dogging event (July 1, 2015)
New battalion commander recalls Floresville roots (July 1, 2015)
Nixon residents respond to shooting with prayer (July 1, 2015)
Parkside Homes wins planning and zoning approval (July 1, 2015)
Scam email: Pay up or die (July 1, 2015)
Skloss retires after four decades with Karnes Electric (July 1, 2015)
Tanker, tow truck crash on U.S. 181 (July 1, 2015)
Tour vintage aircraft at Stinson Municipal Airport (July 1, 2015)
Traps to avoid after graduation (July 1, 2015)